VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Ungawa]

Review bombing

A bit of context here, but games usually get review bombed when something changes in it that that's pretty severe to miss the expectations of the players. A big shift in focus for the developers, as explained above, usually works as a mirror into how a lot of people might not feel an update or event is living up to their standards. And sometimes, people hate an actor or studio for doing something they did not like. It's a way to see what groups of people think or feel on Steam or elsewhere.

For a site like this, we don't really see coordination of events into one big review bomb since this is only thousands of folks finding a fap.

What we do see are Koffing's and they aren't all that coordinated while regulars go into a thread and help keep a strong understanding of strengths and weaknesses that developers might not consider.

Overall, I look at them as a reflection in a point in time but it shouldn't be obsessed over if a developer (or community) feels they have a proper course and vision that may not jibe with the "review bomb's" sentiments.

 

[Deleted member 6943714]

I'm sure someone already pointed this out but this is the first time I noticed it.
Won't bother explaining but, I'm not hallucinating right?

View attachment 3261573

Wait what I never noticed it.. What is this about?

 

[Ungawa]

Any eta yet?

Page 598 got the details here, my guy

 

[Axeleen]

I ...

Seems like you still can't read my comment properly. In any case, if your quote of him accomplishes anything, it's further support of my point ^^. And I knew all this years ago don't worry.

Anyway, always funny how fanboys can be so trigerred and this quickly by a mere joke on a forum . Entertaining as ever

 

[ename144]

Seems like you still can't read my comment properly. In any case, if your quote of him accomplishes anything, it's further support of my point ^^. And I knew all this years ago don't worry.

Anyway, always funny how fanboys can be so trigerred and this quickly by a mere joke on a forum . Entertaining as ever

The quote may not explicitly refute your point, but it certainly doesn't support it. If the ultimate goal of this game was to justify an incest story, why is there never going to be any incest in it? Even if TD decided to change tack because of Patreon rules or something, why would he base the revised project on a setup designed from the keel out to do something counterproductive?

It would be like claiming a submarine was originally designed to fly to Mars purely on the grounds it has a *really* efficient life support system; a quote from the designer disparaging the lazy design of most interplanetary rockets is hardly proof.

 

[Hahn1900]

I'm sure someone already pointed this out but this is the first time I noticed it.
Won't bother explaining but, I'm not hallucinating right?

View attachment 3261573

about what? I dont get it... Its Minas Mom and Brother... and? The hair of mom or what do you mean?

Did you ever heard about hair dye? Or maybe the father is blonde? I for one inherited the haircolor of my grandfather, my father has black hair, my mom brown... i have reddish hair. Its not that uncommon to inherit some major features from a generetion before. Or adoption, but what would that matter anyways? *shrug* I dont know what you mgiht wanna build out of that picture. Wanna be the next x_dalli? So Hana is an alien, cause humans dont have yellow eyes, never ever.

In this "anime" style appearences are not realistic anyway so dont read too much into it.

If you not mean the hair... *shrug* i dont know what you want, and even if you mean the hair, well... nothing to fuss about either.

 

[Deleted member 6943714]

about what? I dont get it... Its Minas Mom and Brother... and? The hair of mom or what do you mean?

Did you ever heard about hair dye? Or maybe the father is blonde? I for one inherited the haircolor of my grandfather, my father has black hair, my mom brown... i have reddish hair. Its not that uncommon to inherit some major features from a generetion before. Or adoption, but what would that matter anyways? *shrug* I dont know what you mgiht wanna build out of that picture. Wanna be the next x_dalli? So Hana is an alien, cause humans dont have yellow eyes, never ever.

In this "anime" style appearences are not realistic anyway so dont read too much into it.

If you not mean the hair... *shrug* i dont know what you want, and even if you mean the hair, well... nothing to fuss about either.

I think He means (and I'm confused too) that this is the MC's mom

 

[Biscardone]

The quote may not explicitly refute your point, but it certainly doesn't support it. If the ultimate goal of this game was to justify an incest story, why is there never going to be any incest in it? Even if TD decided to change tack because of Patreon rules or something, why would he base the revised project on a setup designed from the keel out to do something counterproductive?

It would be like claiming a submarine was originally designed to fly to Mars purely on the grounds it has a *really* efficient life support system; a quote from the designer disparaging the lazy design of most interplanetary rockets is hardly proof.

Well, what you are saying is entirely logic. Unfortunately, Axeleen's argument is that TD and GIL, possibly unbeknownst to themselves, deep down are writing an exploration of oedipal themes and as such it must be resolved, or at least motivated, by incest. Even, and I quote, "if they may never admit this to themselves (or to us)". Logic can't beat mind reading skills, or couch psychoanalysis, I'd say.

 

[Hahn1900]

I think He means (and I'm confused too) that this is the MC's mom

erm no? Well with really really bad eyes you might think that and of course if you skipped most of the game too (cause MCs mom and Mina meet each other in the game and know about each other)... but no they are not the same person, not even close.

Fuck Rosalind looks more like MCs mom than the woman on that picture aka Minas mom.

 

[Deleted member 6943714]

erm no? Well with really really bad eyes you might think that and of course if you skipped most of the game too (cause MCs mom and Mina meet each other in the game and know about each other)... but no they are not the same person, not even close.

Fuck Rosalind looks more like MCs mom than the woman on that picture aka Minas mom.

Wait what? Did Mina meet MCs mom? I think it was hana

 

[Hahn1900]

Wait what? Did Mina meet MCs mom? I think it was hana

Uff.... just.... uff, forget about it, start a new game, at the very beginning you can take a look at MCs mom already, and if you still think that she is the same person like on that picture, well.... *shrug* I guess Ronald McDonald will turn out to be my father, could be worse.

 

[CorprealFale]

I assume it's a transphobic person because someone posted a close-up at Minas pubic area.
It's just someone who doesn't know how a woman looks and assumes "has to be a dick hidden there that isn't there anymore".

 

[Takkatakka]

I really didn't get that post either...maybe it is just trolling/red-herring? If not maybe that user could enlighten us if he/she maybe so inclined.

 

[Bill Temple]

I really didn't get that post either...maybe it is just trolling/red-herring? If not maybe that user could enlighten us if he/she maybe so inclined.

I'm gonna try this in another game thread. I'll post a random but obscure image from the game, and caption it: "You're seeing this right!?! LOL! I won't explain. IYKYK"

 

[dolfe67]

Just ignore it, since he didn't explain what is wrong for him

 

[OUndrAnt]

Bonus Art: Where The Foxes Gather

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Idontplay]

Only one woman with the right amount of clothes.

 

[Bill Temple]

Only one woman with the right amount of clothes.

Andrea.

 

[boy1208]

Is there any way for me to unlock the scenes i didnt choose without having to play through the game again?

 

[Xythurr]

I'm at the part where Kathleen is wanting MC to play with Harper as a birthday gift. I chose all the hardcore options and Kat blueballs the MC.
How do you get her scene?